Character Development Stephen Amell Tim Allen Joshua Jackson Leslie Bibb Jing Lusi Richard Armitage Keri Russell Michelle Pfeiffer Niecy Nash-Betts Actors Shazad Latif Theo James Callum McGowan Joel Edgerton Amandla Stenberg Norman Reedus Melissa McBride Kelly Reilly Cole Hauser Original Cast Members Sophia Bush Hilarie Burton Sydney Sweeney Nicole Kidman Hilarie Burton Morgan Leo Suter Giancarlo Esposito Leslie Uggams Fauji David Harbour Kevin Costner Frankie Muniz Bryan Cranston Jeff Bridges Original Cast Noel Fielding Kristin Kreuk Yvonne Strahovski Sterling K. Brown Sarah Michelle Gellar Returning Characters Zahn McClarnon Noah Centineo