Overview
- Je'Von Evans was named Male Superstar of the Year after winning the Iron Survivor Challenge at Deadline and making recent appearances on Raw and SmackDown, including a WWE World Tag Team Title challenge at Saturday Night's Main Event.
- Sol Ruca earned Female Superstar of the Year following 200 days as Women's Speed champion and 189 as NXT Women's North American champion, capped by a win over former Women's Champion Bayley at Saturday Night's Main Event.
- Zaruca, the pairing of Zaria and Sol Ruca, took Tag Team of the Year in a non-gendered category.
- The NXT Championship triple threat at Stand & Deliver featuring Oba Femi, Je'Von Evans, and Trick Williams was named Match of the Year, and Stand & Deliver received Show of the Year.
- Moment of the Year was announced on NXT social media, honoring Tatum Paxley's NXT Women's Championship win at Halloween Havoc.