Overview
- West Virginia announced McAfee as one of six inductees in its 2025 Sports Hall of Fame class.
- McAfee posted a grateful, profanity-laced message on X and specifically thanked coach Rich Rodriguez for the opportunity to be a Mountaineer.
- At WVU, he was a 2008 first-team All-American and set school records for games played (51), points (384) and extra points made (210).
- He was drafted by the Colts in the seventh round in 2009, earned All-Pro honors in 2014, made the Pro Bowl in 2014 and 2016 and recorded a 41.1 career net punting average.
- Coverage describes the honor as uncommon for a special-teams player and reports that McAfee has previously consulted with AD Wren Baker during a coaching search tied to Rodriguez’s return.