Particle.news

Download on the App Store

World Rugby Defends Referees Over Lions Ruck Call and Exempts Schmidt

World Rugby’s private review of the contentious ruck ruling marks its latest step to reinforce player safety in the lead-up to the deciding Test in Sydney.

Rugby Union - Australia v British and Irish Lions - Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne, Australia - July 26, 2025 British and Irish Lions' Maro Itoje celebrates with the player of the match medal after the match Joel Carrett/AAP Image via REUTERS
Image
Rugby Union - Rugby World Cup Tournament Opening Press Conference - Roland Garros, Paris, France - September 4, 2023 World Rugby CEO, Alan Gilpin during the press conference REUTERS/Sarah Meyssonnier/File Photo

Overview

  • Alan Gilpin publicly backed referee Andrea Piardi’s judgment that Jac Morgan’s clear-out was legal and upheld Hugo Keenan’s last-minute try.
  • The governing body rejected claims that the 79th-minute decision breached player welfare principles, citing its research-driven safety initiatives and recent law evolutions.
  • Gilpin confirmed that Joe Schmidt will face no disciplinary action for his post-match criticism of the ruck ruling.
  • World Rugby is finalizing a confidential review of the refereeing process, with findings to be shared privately with both teams before the third Test.
  • Officials stressed the need to shield referees from public abuse, referencing past mental health impacts on Nic Berry and Wayne Barnes.