Overview
- The court’s Monday order declares Catholic Charities Bureau and its affiliated entities eligible for the religious-purpose exemption to unemployment taxation.
- The justices remanded the case to the circuit court to vacate prior agency rulings and directed the Labor and Industry Review Commission to grant eligibility.
- The decision follows a unanimous U.S. Supreme Court ruling written by Justice Sonia Sotomayor that found Wisconsin’s earlier approach to be unconstitutional denominational discrimination.
- Attorney General Josh Kaul’s request to eliminate the exemption statewide as a remedial measure was rejected by the court.
- The dispute dates to a 2016 denial by the Department of Workforce Development; advocacy groups including Becket and NCLA praised the ruling, and reports have estimated unemployment taxes at roughly $440–$490 per employee per year without the exemption.