Particle.news

VAR Transfers Yellow Card in USA–Paraguay Using New Mistaken‑Identity Protocol

The move used IFAB’s 2026 rule change to remove Tim Ream’s booking and issue a yellow to Miguel Almirón, showing video officials can reverse misidentified disciplinary decisions and creating a live precedent for future matches.

Overview

  • Referee Danny Makkelie first booked U.S. defender Tim Ream for a foul, then went to the pitch monitor after a VAR intervention and removed the yellow following a video review.
  • VAR footage shown on the broadcast labeled the check as “Mistaken Identity” and the angles indicated Almirón appeared to dive, leading Makkelie to reissue the yellow to Paraguayan Miguel Almirón for simulation.
  • The change took place during the USA v Paraguay match at SoFi Stadium and is the first confirmed application of IFAB/FIFA’s mistaken‑identity protocol at a World Cup.
  • Under the 2026 IFAB guidance, video teams may correct yellow or red cards when a player was wrongly identified and the protocol permits review even after play has restarted in narrow cases.
  • The decision underscores practical questions about timing and transparency for VAR reviews and creates a refereeing precedent that could affect how future matches handle identification errors and disciplinary corrections.