Particle.news

Download on the App Store

VAR Overturns Sunderland Penalty at Old Trafford After Pitch-Side Review

The referee reversed the call after a monitor review confirmed no head contact, with the ball already out of play.

Overview

  • Referee Stuart Attwell initially awarded a spot-kick against Benjamin Sesko for a raised foot on Trai Hume before being sent to the pitch-side monitor.
  • The Premier League Match Centre relayed the on-field announcement that there was no foul, no contact with the head, and that the correct restart was a corner.
  • The incident came in first-half stoppage time with Manchester United leading 2-0 through goals from Mason Mount and Sesko.
  • Ex-referee Mike Dean questioned the VAR process and staffing on broadcast, arguing an assistant referee was operating as VAR and that the incident should have been resolved without a review.
  • Dean later clarified the VAR was right to intervene after realizing the penalty had been given on-field, while broader criticism of VAR consistency and accountability continued without any formal PGMOL admission of error.