Overview
- Responding officers found the girls around 3 a.m. on the roof of the last car at Marcy Avenue after the J train crossed the Williamsburg Bridge, and they were pronounced dead at the scene.
- Relatives identified the 12-year-old as Zemfira Mukhtarov, while the other victim is 13, and local outlets reported the pair connected online and left home that night.
- NYC Transit called the event a tragedy as the MTA advances countermeasures, including drone patrols, social‑media content removals, renewed public warnings, and tests of rubber tube barriers between cars.
- An NBC News review counted 18 subway‑surfing deaths in New York across 2023–2024, and police had recorded three such fatalities in 2025 before this incident.
- A wrongful‑death suit by a 2023 victim’s mother alleging TikTok and Meta promoted the behavior remains pending, and the companies have denied the claims.