Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Trump Order Seeks Flag-Desecration Cases as Veteran’s White House Protest Leads to Arrest

Legal scholars say the directive collides with Supreme Court rulings that protect flag burning as expressive speech.

Overview

  • The executive order signed Monday directs Attorney General Pam Bondi to prioritize prosecutions tied to flag desecration and to pursue litigation to test the First Amendment’s limits in such cases.
  • The Justice Department is instructed to examine incidents for violations under other laws, including violent- and hate-crime statutes, civil-rights offenses, property crimes, conspiracies, and aiding and abetting, and to refer qualifying cases to state and local authorities.
  • A man who identified himself as a U.S. Army veteran burned a flag outside the White House the same day the order was signed and was charged under a federal rule prohibiting fires in public parks, according to reports.
  • Texas v. Johnson (1989) and a 1990 follow-on ruling protect flag burning as symbolic speech, a precedent free-speech attorneys say the administration is attempting to narrow through test cases.
  • The order also targets immigration benefits for noncitizens who desecrate the flag, while civil-liberties advocates and some conservatives argue the effort is unconstitutional or invites selective enforcement.