Overview

• Judge Shaun Smith KC lifted reporting restrictions on Hartle’s identity after the defendant turned 18, allowing him to be named for the first time in court.
• Jurors at Derby Crown Court heard that Hartle admits stabbing 18-year-old Noah Smedley but denies murder, claiming he believed Smedley was about to attack him.
• Prosecution outlined how Hartle allegedly concealed an eight- to nine-inch Rambo-style knife, pulled down a balaclava and stabbed Smedley through the heart on December 28, 2024.
• Witnesses described Hartle smiling before the attack and fleeing with friends, disposing of his clothing, knife and mobile phone in an apparent bid to evade capture.
• The trial, expected to last up to three weeks, will consider whether the killing was premeditated or a split-second reaction in self-defence.