Overview
- Baroness Hilary Cass told a parliamentary joint committee on Monday that she could not support the draft because it risked "serious unintended consequences" and could create chilling effects for health staff.
- The draft bill for England and Wales would criminalise 'abusive' attempts to change sexual orientation or gender identity and carry penalties of up to five years in prison and unlimited fines.
- Several clinicians told the committee they had not encountered the kinds of abusive conversion practices described in the draft, saying professional bodies had few or no complaints limited to such practices.
- Critics and some Conservative sources say the published draft omits explicit parental safeguards found in earlier work and could, as worded, catch ordinary family conversations or caregiving decisions.
- The bill remains under pre-legislative scrutiny and ministers say they will take committee evidence into account; the withdrawal of a high-profile expert increases the risk the text will be substantially revised before any legislation proceeds.