Overview
- The film is loosely based on Tom Michell's memoir about rescuing a penguin in the 1970s but significantly fictionalizes the story, including adding a tragic backstory for the protagonist.
- Set during Argentina’s 1976 military coup, the movie juxtaposes lighthearted penguin antics with darker themes of political repression, drawing criticism for tonal inconsistencies.
- Steve Coogan’s portrayal of the protagonist has been widely praised for his comedic timing and emotional depth, standing out as a highlight of the film.
- Critics note the film’s focus on the penguin, Juan Salvador, often overshadows its human characters and their struggles, including a subplot about a young protester abducted by the regime.
- Comparisons to the 2024 film 'My Penguin Friend' have emerged, with critics generally favoring the latter for its more cohesive approach to similar themes.