Particle.news

Download on the App Store

The Penguin Lessons’ Earns Mixed Reviews for Tonal Struggles and Penguin-Centric Focus

Steve Coogan’s performance shines in this adaptation set during Argentina’s 1976 military coup, but critics highlight its uneven storytelling and sidelining of human characters.

Image
Steve Coogan as Tom Michell, from left, and Baba/Richard the penguins as Juan Salvador in “The Penguin Lessons.”
Image
Baba/Richard the penguins as Juan Salvador, left, and Steve Coogan as Tom Michell in “The Penguin Lessons.”

Overview

  • The film is loosely based on Tom Michell's memoir about rescuing a penguin in the 1970s but significantly fictionalizes the story, including adding a tragic backstory for the protagonist.
  • Set during Argentina’s 1976 military coup, the movie juxtaposes lighthearted penguin antics with darker themes of political repression, drawing criticism for tonal inconsistencies.
  • Steve Coogan’s portrayal of the protagonist has been widely praised for his comedic timing and emotional depth, standing out as a highlight of the film.
  • Critics note the film’s focus on the penguin, Juan Salvador, often overshadows its human characters and their struggles, including a subplot about a young protester abducted by the regime.
  • Comparisons to the 2024 film 'My Penguin Friend' have emerged, with critics generally favoring the latter for its more cohesive approach to similar themes.