'The Astronaut' Struggles to Connect at SXSW Premiere

Jess Varley's directorial debut receives criticism for its derivative storytelling and uneven execution despite a strong lead performance by Kate Mara.

• The film, which premiered at SXSW 2025, is a psychological sci-fi thriller about an astronaut's return to Earth after a mysterious space mission.
• Critics noted the movie's reliance on heavy-handed homages to classics like 'E.T.,' 'Close Encounters,' and 'Jurassic Park,' which fail to elevate its narrative.
• Kate Mara's portrayal of astronaut Sam Walker earned praise, but the character's decisions were described as frustratingly illogical by reviewers.
• The film's final act was widely criticized for its rushed pacing, unconvincing twist, and lack of engagement with its moral implications.
• Special effects and tonal shifts were also highlighted as weaknesses, detracting from the overall impact of the story.

3 Articles

SlashFilm IndieWire Deadline