Particle.news

Download on the App Store

TEPJF Upholds Judicial Election, Rejects ‘Acordeón’ Annulment Bid

The decision cements the June results, leaving questions over the origin of vote guides to ongoing INE inquiries.

Norma Piña publicó su último informe de labores al frente de la presidencia de la SCJN. Foto: Cuartoscuro
Foto: Suprema Corte de Justicia de la Nación.
Image
Foto: Especial

Overview

  • Mexico’s electoral tribunal validated the Supreme Court ministers’ vote in a 3–2 ruling, with Mónica Soto, Felipe Fuentes and Felipe de la Mata in the majority and Reyes Rodríguez and Janine Otálora dissenting.
  • The majority held that the presence of vote guides did not prove an illicit, coordinated operation decisive to the outcome, calling the annulment theory unsupported.
  • Reyes Rodríguez cited 3,188 printed guides and 374 digital items plus statistical patterns to argue for nullification, but his project failed to meet the tribunal’s annulment threshold.
  • Janine Otálora said the INE is investigating the provenance and financing of the guides, a process expected to take time and potentially result in sanctions.
  • The nine ministers‑elect are preparing a September 1 installation that includes indigenous purification rites and a solemn session, as outgoing president Norma Piña underscores the need to preserve judicial autonomy after a complex reform period.