Overview
- Justice N. Tukaramji struck down three FIRs against BRS activist Nalla Balu over tweets critical of the Chief Minister, ruling the posts did not meet legal thresholds for the alleged offences.
- The court formalised guidelines for speech-related cases, directing police to verify the complainant’s standing, conduct a preliminary inquiry, apply a high incitement threshold, and seek legal opinion in sensitive matters.
- Defamation was reaffirmed as a non-cognizable offence requiring a complaint from the aggrieved party and magistrate approval, with frivolous or politically motivated complaints to be closed under Section 176(1) BNSS.
- Mechanical arrests were declared impermissible, with the court citing Arnesh Kumar safeguards, criticising illegal entry and arrest in Balu’s case, and stressing proportionality in criminal process.
- A day earlier, Justice K. Lakshman quashed three identical FIRs against BRS leader K.T. Rama Rao over reposting a TV and YouTube report on an alleged exam paper leak, holding multiple FIRs on the same allegation cannot stand.