Particle.news

Technician and Two Firms Convicted Over Argenteuil Elevator Death

The verdict assigns criminal responsibility across the maintenance chain, potentially speeding movement on proposed rules for regular inspections and stricter owner liability.

Overview

  • The tribunal correctionnel de Pontoise convicted 67-year-old technician Jean‑Marc H. of involuntary manslaughter and gave him an 18-month suspended prison sentence in a ruling delivered Wednesday.
  • The technician’s employer, Bagneux Hydraulique, was fined €80,000 and the elevator assembler TK Elevator was fined €225,000, a larger penalty than the prosecutor had sought for the assembler.
  • Court experts traced the collapse to a 2015 repair on the rare hydraulic elevator in which a flexible hydraulic hose was incorrectly connected, a flaw the technician admitted during the trial.
  • The victim’s mother welcomed the decision as relief after an eight-year fight but lawyers for the defendants said they may appeal, and TK Elevator has signalled it will reserve its response.
  • Lawmakers and safety advocates say the ruling could accelerate plans for mandatory technical checks every two years and a no-fault owner liability regime to reduce the need for lengthy civil or criminal battles.