Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Sycamore Gap Tree Vandals Sentenced to Over Four Years in Landmark Case

The case highlights challenges in quantifying cultural loss under criminal law for environmental vandalism.

Overview

  • Daniel Graham and Adam Carruthers each began serving four years and three months after being convicted of felling the iconic Sycamore Gap tree and damaging Hadrian’s Wall.
  • Mrs Justice Christina Lambert applied the London Tree Officers Association’s CAVAT system and confirmed the damage exceeded £5,000, elevating the offence to high-harm criminal damage.
  • The sentencing hearing was live-streamed worldwide, marking the first global broadcast of a criminal trial for environmental vandalism.
  • National Trust Manager Andrew Poad delivered a victim impact statement describing an overwhelming sense of loss and confusion felt around the world.
  • Critics have questioned the proportionality of the sentences, noting that the tree fellingists received longer prison terms than some convicted of serious sexual offences.