Particle.news

Supreme Court Will Hear H‑2A Case Testing Labor Department’s Adjudication Authority

The ruling could limit how federal agencies enforce workplace rules for temporary farm labor.

Overview

  • The Supreme Court, which granted review Monday, will decide if the Labor Department can adjudicate working‑condition disputes for H‑2A farmworkers or must go to federal courts.
  • The case stems from a 2015 inspection at Sun Valley Orchards in New Jersey that led to about $212,000 in fines and nearly $370,000 in back wages over long shifts, crowded housing, and blocked kitchen access.
  • The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a district court’s dismissal and said the dispute must proceed in federal court, citing a 2024 Supreme Court ruling that curtailed in‑house SEC trials.
  • The administration appealed in February, arguing the Labor Department’s in‑house process fits precedent for managing H‑2A compliance, while the farm says agency courts violate Article III.
  • With H‑2A workers accounting for about one‑sixth of U.S. farm labor, the outcome could reshape agency enforcement across programs, with arguments expected in the fall and a decision likely in 2027.