Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Supreme Court Says UNHCR Refugee Cards Have No Legal Force in India

The bench left any protective directions to the National Human Rights Commission.

Overview

  • Hearing a Sudanese man's plea for interim protection, Justices Surya Kant and Joymalya Bagchi criticised the UNHCR for issuing refugee cards, saying the agency had "opened a showroom" in India.
  • The court declined interim relief and disposed of the petition, granting the petitioner liberty to approach the NHRC for directions, including protection from coercive action.
  • The bench reiterated that UNHCR-issued documents do not create enforceable rights under Indian law, noting India's non‑ratification of the Refugee Convention.
  • The petitioner has lived in India since 2013 and is seeking resettlement in Australia, while his wife and children hold UNHCR cards; his counsel sought temporary protection pending that process.
  • Counsel argued the cards follow rigorous verification and can influence administrative treatment by the MHA and FRRO, and flagged recent enforcement drives in Delhi that have heightened community fear.