Supreme Court Says Governments Can't Pocket Windfalls From Property Tax Sales
- The Supreme Court ruled unanimously that state and local governments cannot keep surplus money from selling properties due to unpaid taxes and must pay former owners their fair share.
- The case centered around Geraldine Tyler, 94, who lost her Minnesota condo after failing to pay $15,000 in taxes, interest and fees.
- Hennepin County sold Tyler's condo for $40,000 but kept the full amount, arguing she had essentially abandoned the property.
- The high court rejected that argument and said keeping excess proceeds from tax sales violates the Fifth Amendment.
- The ruling strikes down laws in about a dozen states that allow governments to pocket windfalls from tax foreclosures.