Particle.news

Supreme Court Rules Prisoner Voting Ban Constitutional

The ruling ends years of conflicting lower-court decisions by upholding the Public Offices Election Law.

Overview

  • Japan's Supreme Court Grand Bench issued a unified decision on Wednesday that the Public Offices Election Law provision barring people with finalized death‑penalty or拘禁刑 sentences from voting is constitutional.
  • The court also rejected the plaintiff Yagihashi Kentarō's claim for ¥30,000 in damages for being unable to vote while incarcerated, leaving his challenge to the law unsuccessful.
  • The contested law forbids voting by anyone with a finalized death sentence or拘禁刑, the consolidated term introduced by the June 2025 criminal‑law reform that merged 懲役 and 禁錮 and shifted the statutory emphasis toward rehabilitation.
  • Lower courts had been split on the issue, with Tokyo district and high courts upholding the ban in 2023–24 while the Osaka High Court found a similar restriction unconstitutional in 2013, a disagreement the Supreme Court's ruling now resolves nationwide.
  • The decision keeps the statutory restriction in force for thousands of prisoners and could prompt policy or legislative debate about prisoner reintegration and voting rights, while pre‑conviction detainees and many on parole remain eligible to vote under existing rules.