Particle.news

Supreme Court Rules Ban on Prisoner Voting Constitutional

A 9–6 Grand Bench decision upholds the Public Offices Election Law while calling on the Diet and public to consider whether the rule needs legislative review.

Overview

  • The Supreme Court Grand Bench on Wednesday held that the law barring people serving拘禁刑 or sentenced to death from voting does not violate the constitutional guarantee of adult suffrage.
  • The court rejected the plaintiff Yagihashi Kentarō’s claim for damages, leaving his challenge and similar suits unsuccessful at the highest level.
  • Judges split 9–6, with the majority saying the blanket restriction remains lawful but noting changing views and urging lawmakers and citizens to debate possible reforms.
  • The ruling resolves long‑running conflicts among lower courts — including a 2013 Osaka High Court decision that found the ban unconstitutional and later higher‑court rulings that upheld it.
  • The decision raises policy questions tied to the 2025 penal reform that merged懲役 and禁錮 into拘禁刑 and emphasized rehabilitation, and it leaves room for the Diet to consider targeted changes that could affect roughly 33,700 people in custody.