Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Supreme Court Publishes Redacted Pretrial Rulings in Erin Patterson Case

It illuminates why key allegations were split from the murder trial due to relevance thresholds and prejudice concerns.

Overview

  • The Victorian Supreme Court released Justice Christopher Beale’s redacted pretrial reasons after Patterson’s bid to keep them secret failed
  • The rulings explain why alleged earlier poisoning attempts and poison-related digital records were ruled too prejudicial or temporally remote
  • Beale’s March decision to order a separate trial for alleged 2021–22 poisoning of estranged husband Simon Patterson led to prosecutors dropping those charges before the lunch trial
  • Jurors in the 10-week Morwell trial heard forensic evidence of death cap residue, phone-tower data and witness testimony linking Patterson to the deadly beef Wellington lunch
  • Patterson, found guilty of three murders and one attempted murder, will face a two-day pre-sentence hearing in late August and retains a 28-day window to appeal