Particle.news

Supreme Court Orders Pen Drive Produced and Seeks Precise Transcripts in Wangchuk NSA Case

The bench questioned discrepancies in translated speeches to verify what was actually supplied to the detainee before ruling on the legality of his preventive detention.

Overview

  • The court directed Jodhpur jail to obtain, seal, and send the exact pen drive given to Sonam Wangchuk in custody on September 29, 2025.
  • The bench asked the Centre to file the actual transcripts of speeches relied upon, noting a claimed 7–8 minute translation for what appeared to be a roughly 3‑minute speech and stressing AI‑era accuracy.
  • Kapil Sibal argued that four videos cited in the detention order were not on the original device supplied to Wangchuk and that selective or incorrect transcripts misled the detaining authority.
  • Government counsel defended the NSA detention as lawful, called Wangchuk a “chief provocateur” of the September 24 Leh violence, and said he is medically fit after 24 examinations, opposing release on health grounds.
  • The justices said they will assess the true text versus translations and posted the habeas corpus matter for further hearing on Thursday.