Supreme Court Issues Notice Over Jharkhand High Court’s Years-Long Appeal Delays
The court has demanded a detailed registry report to explain why appeals filed in 2018–19 remain undecided after hearings ended in 2023.
Overview
- A bench of Justices Surya Kant and Joymalya Bagchi formally issued notice to the Jharkhand High Court registry general following a petition by 10 inmates
- Petitioners comprise six death row convicts and four serving life sentences whose appeals were lodged in 2018–19 and heard by 2022–23 without verdicts
- The bench pointed out that the same judge reserved all these appeals, questioning compliance with Jharkhand HC Rules that mandate judgments within six weeks of arguments
- Advocate Fauzia Shakil told the apex court that prolonged pendency breaches convicts’ Article 21 right to speedy justice and exacerbates mental anguish for those awaiting execution
- The notice signals the apex court’s intent to consider measures enforcing statutory timelines and bolstering judicial accountability after recurring delays