Particle.news

Supreme Court Hears Final Arguments in Upper House Vote-Disparity Case

A year-end constitutional ruling could require the Diet to redraw districts or change how the House of Councillors is elected.

Overview

  • The Supreme Court Grand Bench concluded oral arguments in the appeal over the July 2025 House of Councillors election on Wednesday, Oct. 7, 2026, and the court is expected to hand down a constitutional judgment before the end of the year.
  • Plaintiffs from two lawyer groups seek to invalidate the 2025 election, saying the maximum vote-value gap of about 3.13 times violates the constitution’s guarantee of equal voting value.
  • Lower courts have largely pressured the Diet by finding an 'unconstitutional state' in 11 cases versus 'constitutional' in 5, criticizing lawmakers for taking no corrective steps since 2022.
  • At the hearing plaintiffs urged a fundamental overhaul of the Upper House system while the election commission argued that merged districts introduced in 2016 kept disparities near threefold and therefore do not show 'marked' inequality.
  • The case will turn on the established two-step legal test that asks whether vote value is 'markedly' unequal and whether a reasonable period for legislative correction has passed, and a ruling for plaintiffs could prompt changes to merged districts such as Tottori–Shimane and Tokushima–Kochi or other electoral reforms.