Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Study Detects Vowel‑Like Patterns in Sperm Whale Clicks, Prompting Scientific Debate

The finding faces immediate scrutiny from marine biologists urging replication with contextual tests.

Overview

  • Project CETI and UC Berkeley reported on November 12 in Open Mind that sperm whale codas show discrete vowel‑like categories they term a‑codas and i‑codas.
  • Using a generative adversarial network and linguistic tools, researchers highlighted frequency modulations within codas after removing gaps between clicks to alter human perception of timing.
  • The team describes rising, falling, and combined modulations within these categories, suggesting controlled acoustic variation beyond click counts and spacing.
  • Several marine biologists question the vowel analogy, proposing recording artifacts or arousal state as more plausible explanations and noting a lack of evidence for whale responses to these patterns.
  • CETI says similar patterns appear in independently recorded datasets and is collecting behavioral and locational data to test whether the distinctions carry meaning.