Overview
- A national student-level analysis released Tuesday, November 17 found modest gains in math and reading after schools adopted strict bell-to-bell phone bans, using anonymized NWEA MAP scores from about 3.3 million students at roughly 4,600 schools from 2021–22 through 2025–26.
- The reported annual effect is very small—about 0.01 standard deviations, which researchers equate to roughly one to two weeks of extra instruction per year—but the authors say small yearly gains could accumulate over time.
- Gains were largest where phones were physically locked away; the study’s geolocation data showed roughly a 20 percent drop in on-campus phone activity at schools using lockable pouches.
- The evidence base remains mixed: an earlier national study published in May found close-to-zero effects and some research recorded short-term rises in disciplinary actions after bans, so experts urge caution about broad claims of effectiveness.
- Policymakers face trade-offs in costs and enforcement—pouches cost about $25–$30 per student—and researchers say a key unresolved question is students’ phone and social media use outside school, which will require new platform-level data to assess longer-term impacts.