STF Rules Funrural Charge on Producers' Gross Revenue Unconstitutional Before 2018
The decision preserves the post‑2018 law's regime while leaving refund claims open and creating scope for review by successor justices.
Overview
- The Supreme Court declared the contribution on the gross revenue of individual rural producers and the buyer sub‑rogation rule unconstitutional for the period prior to January 1, 2018.
- The court held that Law 13.606/2018 established a new legal framework from 2018 onward that allows employers in agriculture to choose annually between taxing gross revenue or payroll, and that regime stands.
- A majority outcome followed the median vote of Justice Dias Toffoli, who limited the inconstitutionality to the pre‑2018 period and rejected a complete, timeless annulment of the old rule.
- The court declined to modulate effects now, so claims for retroactive refunds remain possible and unresolved pending further litigation.
- Justice Alexandre de Moraes said the issue may be reheard in embargoes, and four justices who voted have since retired, so successor magistrates could shape the final outcome on reimbursement and scope.