Overview
- The Primeira Turma will vote in a virtual session from 20 to 30 November on whether to receive a PGR denúncia that would make Marcel van Hattem a réu in case Inq 4978.
- Relator Flávio Dino on 19 November denied the defense’s request to move the matter to a presencial hearing, leaving the case to be decided by electronic votes unless another minister seeks destaque.
- The complaint stems from an August 2024 speech in the Chamber in which van Hattem accused PF delegate Fábio Alvarez Shor of producing fraudulent reports; the PF indiciou him in November 2024 and the PGR filed the denúncia in April 2026.
- Van Hattem and his lawyer Alexandre Wunderlich argue the case raises immunity questions and have asked for live sustentação oral, while the deputy has publicly accused the court of political persecution and warned of possible prison time if the complaint is received.
- If the Primeira Turma accepts the denúncia the process will open as a criminal action at the STF, a development that could shift resolution of parliamentary excesses from the Chamber’s ethics system to the criminal courts and reshape how speech from the tribune is policed.