Overview
- The Procuradoria-Geral da República has accused deputy Marcel van Hattem of calúnia and injúria over an August 2024 speech that said PF delegate Fábio Alvarez Shor produced fraudulent reports.
- Relator minister Flávio Dino set a virtual session of the STF 1ª Turma for the period of November 20–30 to decide whether to receive the PGR's denunciation, which would make Van Hattem a criminal defendant if accepted.
- The Conselho Federal da OAB asked on Thursday, November 19, that the 1ª Turma hold a presencial hearing and allow the bar to act as assistant to defend lawyers’ prerogatives, arguing prerecorded submissions limit real-time deliberation.
- Van Hattem’s legal team asked Dino to reconsider the virtual format and sought institutional backing from the OAB while the deputy publicly defended parliamentary immunity and threatened political reprisals including minister impeachments.
- The panel set to vote includes ministers Flávio Dino, Alexandre de Moraes, Cármen Lúcia and Cristiano Zanin and the ruling could clarify the scope of parliamentary inviolability under Article 53 and affect relations between the court and political allies who have voiced solidarity.