Overview
- The 45th Civil Court in São Paulo rejected Renan Santos’s emergency request to take down social posts on May 12, 2026, and the 10th Civil Chamber of the state court upheld that denial on June 11, 2026.
- Both decisions said content removal is an exceptional remedy and found the contested posts simply referenced a real 2021 boletim de ocorrência rather than asserting a proven criminal conviction.
- Judges said Renan’s filings did not present robust evidence that the posts were manifestly false or that a formal criminal acquittal had occurred, so immediate judicial intervention was not justified.
- The lawsuit names individual profiles, including Elias Pereira Freitas da Silva Junior (JR Freitas), and corporate entities X Brasil and Meta’s local branches; defendants have said they will not remove the material.
- With the posts remaining online, the civil case will continue on the merits and the rulings underscore how Brazilian courts set a high bar for takedowns in political debates, a precedent that could shape campaign reporting and platform duties in the 2026 election cycle.