Overview
- The Órgão Especial of the Tribunal de Justiça de São Paulo declared the July 2024 “revisão da revisão” unconstitutional, reverting the city’s parceling, use and occupancy rules to the version sanctioned in January 2024.
- The court majority accepted a petition from the Ministério Público de São Paulo, saying dozens of late substitutives and emendas were added without the required public hearings and amounted to a formal procedural vice.
- Judges kept valid the building permits already issued under the challenged July rules but made the broader effect of the ruling conditional on publication of the court’s acórdão and subject to appeals to the Supreme Court.
- City hall and the Câmara say they will assess appeals and maintain they followed legal procedures, leaving developers and residents with renewed regulatory uncertainty over which parcels and uses are permitted.
- The decision follows a long legal sequence of injunctions and reversals that suspended permit issuance early this year and shows that procedural flaws in municipal zoning edits can quickly reshape urban development rules.