Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Sir Chris Whitty Says Outdoor Covid Limits Were Too Strict, Defends First-Wave School Closures

He told the UK Covid-19 Inquiry he relied on early modelling indicating school closures would cut the first-wave peak.

Overview

  • England’s chief medical officer said he could not see an infection-control rationale for limiting time outside and would have preferred a more liberal approach to children’s play.
  • He testified that playgrounds were kept closed too long, noting Sage judged by mid-April 2020 that outdoor settings were far safer than indoor ones.
  • Schools in England shut to most pupils on March 20, 2020, and he said keeping them open would have raised the peak and increased deaths in the first wave.
  • Whitty said the evidence cannot precisely isolate the effect of school closures from other behavioural changes, though he believes closures significantly drove infections down.
  • He cited March 18, 2020 data showing a rapid upswing in cases and modelling that closures would materially reduce the R value, while warning about risks from households mixing at school gates.