Particle.news

Download on the App Store

SFUSD Cancels Equity-Grading Overhaul After Backlash

Superintendent Maria Su shelved the controversial grading reform owing to transparency concerns coupled with warnings it would undermine academic standards.

School Buses in San Francisco, California.
The Mission High School and its distinctive tower in the Mission District.
SFUSD Superintendent Maria Su backed off a plan for a pilot program to look at different ways of grading students after backlash.
Image

Overview

  • The policy would have evaluated students solely on a retake-friendly final exam, removing homework, participation, and attendance from grade calculations.
  • It aimed to lower the threshold for passing grades to as little as 21 percent for a D and 41 percent for a C, with an A attainable at 80 percent.
  • Superintendent Maria Su introduced the plan without formal Board of Education approval, prompting criticism over governance and lack of community engagement.
  • Local leaders including Mayor Daniel Lurie, Rep. Ro Khanna and San Jose Mayor Matt Mahan publicly denounced the proposal for risking academic rigor and college readiness.
  • District officials said they will engage parents, teachers and board members before considering future grading reforms.