Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Ryan Murphy’s ‘American Love Story’ Costume Tests Face Backlash Over Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy Portrayal

Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy’s former hair colorist has raised accuracy concerns over test images released during ongoing filming for a February 2026 Hulu debut.

Image
A tortoise shell headband and kick-flare jeans are among the key elements of Bessette-Kennedy's signature look.
The fashion publicist's laid-back style has been lauded for more than two decades.
Image

Overview

  • Filming kicked off in June 2025 in New York City and the series is scheduled to premiere on Hulu during Valentine’s Day week of 2026.
  • Released lighting and camera test photos showing Sarah Pidgeon in a stiff camel coat, rigid Birkin bag and pleather blazer with Converse sneakers provoked widespread disappointment among fans.
  • Brad Johns, Bessette-Kennedy’s former hair colorist, told Vogue that Pidgeon’s near-platinum blonde look is “totally wrong” and too modern compared with the original toffee-blonde tone.
  • Critics argue the use of Chuck Taylors clashes with the late icon’s minimalist elegance, though author Elizabeth Beller noted that Carolyn occasionally paired Converse with bohemian dresses off duty.
  • Producers say the circulated images were solely test shots aimed at preempting paparazzi, and they do not represent the final costume designs.