Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Replay Overturns Targeting on Ohio State’s Caleb Downs, Drawing Criticism From Rules Analysts

The decision keeps the All-American eligible for Ohio State’s next game under NCAA targeting rules.

Overview

  • Officials initially flagged Downs for targeting on a late fourth-quarter hit to Penn State’s Khalil Dinkins, then removed targeting on review but enforced a 15-yard personal-foul penalty.
  • Fox rules analyst Mike Pereira and NBC analyst Terry McAulay said the play met targeting criteria, citing a launch and forcible contact to the head or neck of a defenseless receiver.
  • Pereira explained on the broadcast that the personal-foul yardage would remain even if targeting was taken off, which is how the ruling was announced.
  • A confirmed targeting would have required an immediate ejection and a first-half suspension for Ohio State’s next game at Purdue under NCAA policy.
  • The call and reversal intensified long-running complaints about inconsistent replay enforcement of the targeting rule during Ohio State’s 38–14 win over Penn State.