Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Replay Overturn Erases Tigers Run in AL Wild Card Game After McKinstry Ruled Out at Third

The decision came from New York under MLB's clear-and-convincing review standard, prompting questions about the evidence shown on broadcasts.

Overview

  • In the fourth inning of Game 2, Javy Baez singled with the bases loaded as Cleveland challenged a close play at third.
  • Replay officials ruled Jose Ramirez tagged Zach McKinstry before he reached the bag, overturning the on-field safe call.
  • Because Dillon Dingler had not touched home before the third out, his run was taken off the board and the inning ended 1-1.
  • MLB policy requires clear and convincing evidence to overturn, a threshold some analysts argued was not met by available angles.
  • Commentators also criticized McKinstry’s baserunning and slide in a rare sequence that cut short a potential Detroit rally.