Rapper Pras Michél Challenges Conviction, Claims Lawyer's Use of AI Compromised Defence

Michél Alleges Former Attorney's Use of AI Application EyeLevel.AI for Constructing Trial Closing Arguments Resulted in Compromised Defense, Potential Setback for AI's Integration into Legal System.

• Former Fugees member Pras Michél is challenging his recent conviction on conspiracy charges, arguing that his defense was compromised by his former attorney's use of an AI program, EyeLevel.AI, to construct closing arguments.
• Michél alleges that his former attorney, David Kenner, used the AI program to create a closing argument that effectively admitted guilt and neglected key defense arguments, severely prejudicing the defense.
• Kenner allegedly used the AI due to its purported efficiency, transforming hours or days of legal work into seconds. However, Michél's new attorneys argue that the AI failed to serve the defense effectively, leading to a deficient and unhelpful closing argument.
• EyeLevel.AI, the company behind the AI used in the defense, made history as the first use of generative AI in a federal trial. The company insists that the AI tech is an assistance tool for lawyers, rather than a replacement, and denies the allegations of improper use.
• The use of AI in the courtroom is largely uncharted territory, and Michél's appeal could set a precedent for the legal system. Experts warn of the potential pitfalls of trusting machine-generated content in high-stakes scenarios like legal trials, and highlight the need for thorough vetting and potential regulation of AI technologies in legal practices.

3 Articles

Vulture Forbes Forbes