Overview

• Assistant District Attorney Joel Seidemann said the subpoena targeted only Mangione’s insurance account number and coverage period.
• Prosecutors reported that Aetna over-produced confidential medical files beyond the subpoena’s scope.
• The excess records were deleted upon discovery and the court and defense were promptly notified.
• Defense lawyers then inadvertently emailed the full Aetna file back to prosecutors after it had been deleted.
• Prosecutors asked a judge to deny the defense’s motion to suppress the records and to set a trial date.