Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Plaintiffs Seek Contempt Ruling Against Argentina in New York YPF Case Over Discovery

The filing asks Judge Loretta Preska to consider coercive penalties in hearings set for March.

Overview

  • Petersen and Eton Park moved to have Argentina held in contempt, alleging failures to produce emails and WhatsApp messages required by a July 29, 2025 discovery order that included communications from Sergio Massa and Luis Caputo.
  • The plaintiffs seek civil sanctions, an adverse presumption over unproduced evidence, a coercive fine reportedly set at US$1 million per day, and alter-ego findings for entities such as the central bank, Banco Nación, YPF, and Aerolíneas Argentinas.
  • Argentina’s legal team rejects the accusation, says the country is complying with court directives, and argues sanctions would be premature, with a formal response due on February 19.
  • Court filings set a reply from the plaintiffs for March 5 and evidentiary hearings in late March, including March 23–24, where Judge Preska will consider contempt and any sanctions.
  • The enforcement fight follows Preska’s 2023 first-instance judgment of about US$16.1 billion plus interest over the 2012 expropriation of YPF, which Argentina continues to appeal.