Overview
- Judge Nompumelelo Hadebe set aside the original finding of an accidental train strike and found Luthuli died from assault-related head injuries including a skull fracture and cerebral haemorrhage.
- The court identified specific railway and police personnel as implicated, naming train driver Stephanus Albertus Lategan, fireman Daniel Greyling, conductor Pieter van Wyk and detective sergeant Charles Barend Petrus Lewis.
- Crimes cited include defeating the ends of justice, perjury and being accessories after the fact to murder, with the court noting that most named individuals’ whereabouts are unknown.
- The judgment recommended that the Director of Public Prosecutions investigate the kidnapping and disappearance of alleged eyewitness Mbhemu Myandu.
- The inquest was reopened by the National Prosecuting Authority in April 2025, and Justice Minister Mmamoloko Kubayi publicly welcomed the court’s decision.
 
  
 