Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Phillies–Realmuto Talks Stall as Padres Buzz Grows and Catcher Contingency Plans Emerge

Philadelphia is preparing fallback plans at catcher, including promoting Rafael Marchán or pursuing Victor Caratini if negotiations do not restart.

Overview

  • Team president Dave Dombrowski again labeled catcher the club’s top focus, yet J.T. Realmuto remains unsigned heading into January.
  • Reports describe a gap on contract terms, with Philadelphia believed to favor about two years in the $30–35 million range against industry projections near $34 million.
  • Analysts and outlets increasingly predict Realmuto could land with the Padres, framing the San Diego fit as plausible rather than certain.
  • The Phillies are evaluating internal and external options, with Marchán gaining reps in winter ball and Victor Caratini cited as a lower-cost alternative or part of a tandem.
  • Marchán recently referred to learning from Realmuto in the “final years” of his career, as the 34-year-old posted a .257/.315/.384 line with 12 homers and roughly 2.1 fWAR in 2025.