Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Oprah Picks Elizabeth Gilbert’s Memoir as Debate Over Its Ethics Grows

Critics question consent after Gilbert writes that a visit from Elias’s ghost cleared her to tell their story.

Overview

  • Oprah Winfrey named All the Way to the River her latest book club selection and released an interview with Gilbert recorded at a Seattle Starbucks.
  • Published this week by Bloomsbury, the memoir centers on Gilbert’s relationship with Rayya Elias, who died in 2018.
  • Reviews note Gilbert’s admissions about being overwhelmed as a caregiver, including thoughts of killing Elias and herself and her enabling of drug use.
  • Coverage highlights Gilbert’s account of channeling Elias’s ghost for authorization to disclose intimate details, prompting questions about consent.
  • The book has drawn wide online discussion following an excerpt in The Cut and a New Yorker review by Jia Tolentino.