Overview

• Jury selection wrapped on July 14, and opening statements began this week in Manhattan Criminal Court for Ian McKeever’s misdemeanor animal cruelty case.
• Prosecutors argued that McKeever drove Ryder beyond its limits on a sweltering day, presenting bystander video and testimony to show neglect and exhaustion.
• Witnesses including bystander Caroline Londahl-Smidt and an NYPD mounted unit officer recounted seeing the horse’s visible distress, collapse on Ninth Avenue, and efforts to cool and reposition the animal.
• Defense attorney Raymond Loving asserted that Ryder simply tripped and suffered no heat-related injury, and McKeever, who pleaded not guilty, could face up to a year in jail if convicted.
• The trial has reignited debate over the future of New York City’s carriage horse industry, with activists pushing for a ban and the drivers’ union proposing stricter oversight and training.