Particle.news
Download on the App Store

One-Punch Man Episode 9 Chooses Early Manga Version, Fueling Fan Dispute Over Cut Story Beats

The decision underscores production strain, diverging manga versions, limited Saitama presence.

Overview

  • Episode 9 adapts the first published version of the Child Emperor–Phoenix Man showdown, shifting debate from animation quality to which manga iteration the anime follows.
  • Critics say the choice omits redrawn material that foreshadows larger mysteries and adds character moments, including telepathic elements and a scene with Zombieman.
  • Reviewers note a visual uptick compared with most of season 3, though assessments of the episode’s engagement vary from reserved praise to describing it as forgettable.
  • Some viewers favor the fight-forward approach that lets supporting heroes take the spotlight, while others argue the anime should have blended key beats from both manga versions.
  • Commentary continues to cite a compressed schedule and Murata’s frequent redraws as adaptation hurdles, with concerns about Saitama’s minimal screen time and an uncertain runway for the short season.