October 2025 City Guides Reveal Cheapest Auto Insurance by City and Violation Penalties
Way.com's October analysis draws on insurer filings to pinpoint local price leaders.
Overview
- San Diego’s lowest rates come from CSAA at $26 per month for liability and $109 for full coverage, with an average baseline premium of $185 before violations.
- Los Angeles drivers see CSAA lead at $37 for liability and $153 for full coverage, while average premiums jump from a $260 baseline to $676 after a DUI in the guide’s scenarios.
- In Denver, American National offers the cheapest liability at $26, and the guide’s full-coverage table lists Colorado Farm Bureau as the lowest at $74, with a $265 no-violation average.
- Portland’s cheapest options are from Kemper at $51 for liability and $83 for full coverage, with average premiums modeled at $179 for drivers without violations.
- Phoenix’s guide lists the lowest liability at $59 with Mercury and a $109 lowest full-coverage price, though the provider attribution for that $109 rate is inconsistent within the article.