Particle.news

Download on the App Store

NTSB Blames Overloading and Antlers for 2023 Alaska Crash; Widow Files Negligence Suit

Mary Peltola’s lawsuit follows confirmation that the Super Cub exceeded its weight limit by 117 pounds with unapproved external antlers.

FILE - Eugene "Buzzy" Peltola Jr. holds the Bible during a ceremonial swearing-in for his wife, Rep. Mary Peltola, D-Alaska, on Capitol Hill in Washington, Sept. 13, 2022. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana, File)
The Piper PA-18 plane the NTSB determined was overloaded with moose meat and antlers hanging on the wing when it took on September 12, 2023, seen in a still image from video reviewed by the NTSB in their final report.NTSB photo of the crash site of the Piper PA-18 near St. Mary’s, Alaska in September of 2023, from investigator’s final report.
Image
The Piper PA-18 plane the NTSB determined was overloaded with moose meat and antlers when it took on September 12, 2023, seen in a still image from bystander video reviewed by the NTSB in their report. A portion of this image has been obscured by the NTSB.

Overview

  • The NTSB’s final report identifies 520 pounds of moose meat—117 pounds over the Piper PA-18 Super Cub’s maximum takeoff weight—as a primary cause of the crash.
  • Investigators found a set of moose antlers mounted on the right wing strut without FAA approval, creating additional drag and a lateral weight imbalance.
  • Turbulent downdrafts at the remote St. Mary’s airstrip prevented the overloaded plane from gaining sufficient power or control authority to clear nearby terrain.
  • Two hunters rendered aid at the crash site but the 400-mile distance from the nearest hospital made prompt medical treatment impossible, resulting in Peltola’s death within two hours.
  • On July 18, Mary Peltola filed a civil negligence suit against her husband’s employer and the aircraft owner, alleging dangerous operating conditions and regulatory noncompliance.