Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Noem Criticized for Misrepresenting Survivor Data and Delaying Texas Flood Aid

Tagnawa researchers say she distorted a survival sex statistic; her rule requiring personal approval of large expenditures delayed flood rescue by more than 72 hours.

Image
Image
Law enforcement work to retrieve a deceased person near Camp Mystic in Hunt, Texas, on July 7, 2025.

Overview

  • At a July 9 FEMA review, Noem claimed one in six Lahaina wildfire survivors were forced into survival sex for supplies based on a Tagnawa report.
  • Khara Jabola-Carolus, a Tagnawa researcher, labeled Noem’s citation of the 16 percent figure a gross manipulation that ran counter to the study’s intent.
  • CNN and New York Times sources report that Noem’s policy requiring her approval on DHS spending over $100,000 stalled FEMA’s flood response, delaying urban search and rescue teams for more than three days.
  • On July 9, DHS blasted the delay reports as a “FAKE NEWS LIE” and defended Noem’s leadership, saying federal assets helped save over 900 lives.
  • Noem’s push to eliminate and rebuild FEMA has spurred bipartisan scrutiny over shifting disaster response authority and ensuring accountability.