Overview
- A three‑judge Ninth Circuit panel on Wednesday reversed a lower court and found two California tribes likely to succeed under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA), returning the case for the district court to decide on a preliminary injunction against Kalshi’s sports event contracts on tribal lands.
- The ruling follows an August 28 Ninth Circuit opinion that said sports‑linked event contracts are not federal swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, a conclusion that allowed Nevada to assert gaming oversight over those products.
- Conflicting appellate rulings have created a circuit split because a separate Third Circuit decision treated the same products as federally preempted swaps, making Supreme Court review or congressional clarification more likely.
- Kalshi says it may appeal and argues its contracts are CFTC‑regulated financial products, while Robinhood and other distributors are reviewing legal options and state and tribal officials are pressing enforcement and injunctive remedies.
- Practical effects already in play include possible geofencing and blocked access on reservations, the risk of state fines or injunctions, and strain on tribal gaming revenue and consumer protections such as age limits, licensing and problem‑gambling safeguards.